There’s a strange contradiction I’ve noticed about reading.
Sometimes life gets stressful. Work becomes overwhelming, responsibilities pile up, or something is weighing heavily on your mind.
And suddenly, reading becomes almost impossible.
You pick up a book you’re genuinely enjoying. You’re invested in the characters, eager to know what happens next, and there’s absolutely nothing wrong with the story.
But you can’t concentrate.
You read a paragraph and realize you haven’t absorbed a word. You try again, only to find your thoughts drifting back to whatever has been bothering you.
Eventually, you put the book down.
Then you pick up your phone.
And somehow, you can spend the next hour scrolling through news, social media, videos and whatever else the algorithm decides to put in front of you.
The strangest part?
You might even feel guilty about spending time with a book, yet feel almost no guilt about spending twice as long scrolling through your phone.
Why is that?
Reading requires something scrolling doesn’t
Reading fiction demands a particular kind of attention.
We’re following characters, remembering events, imagining environments and connecting things that might have happened hundreds of pages earlier.
A good novel asks us to temporarily inhabit another world.
And that requires mental space.
Stress has a way of occupying that space.
A 2016 meta-analysis published in Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews found that acute stress tended to impair working memory and cognitive flexibility.
In simpler terms, stress can make it harder to hold information in mind and shift attention between competing demands.
Another meta-analysis published in Psychonomic Bulletin & Review found an overall negative relationship between mind wandering and reading comprehension.
Anyone who’s repeatedly read the same page while thinking about something else probably recognizes the experience.
But scrolling is different.
A social media feed rarely asks us to remember what happened five minutes ago.
One video ends. Another begins.
A headline appears. We glance at it.
A photograph, a joke, an argument, another headline.
There’s no complicated narrative to reconstruct when our attention wanders. We simply move to the next thing.
Scrolling accommodates a distracted mind. Reading asks us to concentrate it.
And when we’re stressed, the easier option often wins.
The strange guilt of doing something enjoyable
But difficulty concentrating doesn’t explain everything.
Why can reading feel irresponsible when scrolling doesn’t?
Psychologists have studied how our attitudes toward leisure affect our ability to enjoy it.
In a 2021 study published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, researchers found that people who viewed leisure as wasteful tended to enjoy leisure activities less, particularly activities pursued simply for pleasure.
Think about that.
We can become so accustomed to measuring our time in terms of productivity that even doing something we love begins to feel like something we need to justify.
Reading a novel is a deliberate choice.
We sit down, open a book and consciously decide to spend time doing something enjoyable.
And when life feels unsettled, that decision can come with an uncomfortable thought.
Shouldn’t I be doing something more important?
Scrolling, on the other hand, often doesn’t feel like a decision at all.
We pick up our phones almost automatically.
We’re checking the news. Seeing what’s happening. Catching up on something.
Or so we tell ourselves.
Ten minutes becomes thirty. Thirty becomes sixty.
And somehow, an hour disappears without our ever consciously deciding to spend it that way.
Maybe reading makes us feel guilty because we’re consciously choosing leisure, while scrolling allows us to waste time without fully acknowledging that we’ve chosen to.
That’s my interpretation, not a conclusion established by the research. But it might explain why two activities that occupy the same amount of time can feel so different.
The illusion of staying informed
Sometimes we’re not scrolling because we’re bored.
We’re looking for answers.
When something feels uncertain or threatening, checking the news can create the impression that we’re doing something useful.
Perhaps the next article will explain what’s happening.
Perhaps the next discussion will provide reassurance.
Perhaps the next update will make things clearer.
But there’s always another article.
Another prediction.
Another alarming headline.
And that’s where ordinary scrolling can become doomscrolling.
A 2026 systematic review and meta-analysis published in Frontiers in Psychology examined the relationship between doomscrolling and psychological well-being.
The researchers found associations between repetitive consumption of distressing online information and poorer mental-health outcomes, while emphasizing that much of the evidence was correlational and its certainty was limited.
In other words, doomscrolling may accompany distress without necessarily being its cause.
But the contradiction remains.
We reach for our phones because we’re worried, only to encounter more reasons to worry.
And unlike a novel, which asks us to temporarily disengage from our immediate concerns, doomscrolling can make us feel as though we’re remaining connected to them.
Even when that connection isn’t helping.
We can mistake consuming information for doing something about the information we’re consuming.
Meanwhile, the book remains unopened.
Why is escaping into fiction so difficult?
One of the great pleasures of fiction is its ability to transport us somewhere else.
For a little while, our problems can fade into the background.
We can explore distant planets, wander through imaginary kingdoms or experience lives entirely different from our own.
It’s one of the reasons people read in the first place.
And yet, when we might benefit most from that escape, we sometimes find ourselves unable to enjoy it.
Perhaps that’s because becoming immersed in a story requires us to temporarily surrender our attention to something unrelated to our immediate concerns.
And when those concerns feel urgent, letting go can be uncomfortable.
Of course, this isn’t everyone’s experience.
Some people turn to fiction precisely because they’re stressed. Reading can provide comfort and relief. Others find that stress makes reading harder.
The same person might experience both reactions at different times.
The point isn’t that stress inevitably prevents us from reading.
It’s that our ability to enjoy something isn’t determined solely by how much we love it.
Sometimes it also depends on how much attention we’re able to give it.
The problem with waiting for the perfect moment
There’s a temptation to tell ourselves we’ll return to reading when things settle down.
When work gets easier.
When the news becomes less alarming.
When our responsibilities feel manageable.
When we finally have enough peace of mind to enjoy a book without distraction.
But when exactly is that supposed to happen?
Life rarely provides a moment when every problem has been resolved and every uncertainty eliminated.
There’s always another responsibility waiting.
Another headline.
Another reason to worry.
And if we insist on resolving all of them before allowing ourselves to enjoy something, we may find ourselves waiting a very long time.
Perhaps the answer isn’t to force ourselves through fifty pages when our minds are elsewhere.
Maybe it’s simply to stop treating reading as something that requires ideal circumstances.
Ten minutes with a book can be enough.
A few pages still count.
And if we find ourselves distracted, perhaps that’s a reason to be patient rather than frustrated.
We’ve already turned enough of life into a series of goals and obligations. Reading doesn’t need to become another one.
Sometimes it’s okay to put a book down. Sometimes it’s okay to read only a few pages.
Reading is supposed to be enjoyable.
Less scrolling. More reading. Easier said than done.
There’s a reason I believe in spending less time scrolling and more time reading.
A good book offers something an endless feed rarely does.
Continuity.
Depth.
The opportunity to spend meaningful time with a story, an idea or another person’s imagination.
I’ve written before about the books that brought me back to reading, and how easily our attention can drift away from something we once loved.
But getting back into reading isn’t always as simple as putting down your phone and picking up a book.
Stress changes how we direct our attention.
Worry makes it difficult to disengage.
And the technology we turn to for distraction can keep pulling us toward the very things we’re trying to escape.
Perhaps the first step is simply recognizing the contradiction.
We can spend an hour scrolling through things we barely remember without giving it a second thought.
Yet somehow, spending that same hour enjoying a novel can feel like an indulgence.
Maybe we’ve got that backward.
And if the habit has slipped away, there are plenty of ways to find your way back into reading without making it another chore.
Because the world isn’t going to stop being complicated.
Our responsibilities aren’t going to disappear.
And there will always be another headline waiting for us.
But the book will still be there.
And we shouldn’t have to wait until everything in life is going well before giving ourselves permission to open it.
Not sure what’s next?
Tell us which stories and ideas stay with you. Find a book that fits your taste today.
Find my next book